This project was assisted by a grant from the Upper Delaware Council, Narrowsburg, NY 12764

Town of Tusten

Town of Tusten  © | Privacy Policy

Sullivan County, NY

Eagle Capital of New York State

Sullivan Legal Aid Panel, Inc.

Tim Havas, Executive Director

11 Bank Street

Monticello, NY 12701

Monticello, NY 12701

Phone: (845) 794-3344

Fax: (845) 794-3646

photos by Kelly Dean 

Phone: (845) 252-7146 prompt 5

Fax: (845) 252-7476

Office Hours:

Tues (12 - 4pm)

Thursday (1230pm - 4pm)

Friday (8am - 10am


Jocelyn Strumpfler, Court Clerk

Thomas H. Nuttycombe, 1st and 2nd Thursday 5pm

David H. Casey 2nd and 3rd Thursday 5pm

The Town Justices perform marriage ceremonies by appointment. 

The Town of Tusten Justice Court handles all traffic tickets, small claims, criminal offenses, and civil cases within the town limits.  Both Town Justices are elected officials, each serving a four year term. 

Forms, Links, and Legal COntacts

Frequently Asked Questions

If I receive a traffic ticket, how do I know how much the fine is?

You must sign the ticket either "Guilty" or "Not Guilty" and send the ticket to the court.  If you plead "Guilty" the court will send you a notice indicating the fine.  If you plead "Not Guilty", the court will send you a notice advising you of a pretrial conference date. 

Honorable Thomas Nuttycombe

Honorable David Casey

Court Clerk - Jocelyn Strumpfler

Court is held every 1st and 2nd Thursday of the month at 5:00pm.

Mailing Address:

210 Bridge Street

PO Box 195

Narrowsburg, NY 12764

Physical ADDRESS:

(do not use for US MAIL)
210 Bridge St. Narrowsburg, NY 12764

Sullivan County Sherrif's Department & Jail

4 Bushnell Avenue

Monticello, NY 12701

(845) 794-0119

Sullivan County District Attorney

James R. Farrell

Lawrence H. Cooke Courthouse

414 Broadway

               Justice Court

NYS Unified Court System

(Forms, Lawyers, The Law & Court Facts)